What does Plato say about the self?

Self as immortal soul, tripartite: rational, spirited, appetitive​

By Shawn Buckles

Dive into Plato's exploration of the self, where the immortal soul's quest for knowledge shapes reality, ethics, and societal health, guiding you beyond the physical to the realm of eternal Forms.

Plato saw the self as made up of rational, spirited, and appetitive parts. He argued for the dominance of rationality, with spirited and appetitive aspects in support, stressing self-knowledge for harmony and moral integrity, essential for a good life.

The soul of man is immortal and imperishable.
Plato
The soul takes nothing with her to the next world but her education and her culture. At the beginning of the journey to the next world, the guardian angel of each person writes on his forehead what he has become through education and culture.
Plato
For the soul, I said, has the elements of knowledge always in herself, and can be reminded of them, or can discover them for herself, if by effort and time and the pursuit of wisdom she attracts them to her.
Plato

Summary

  • The self, according to Plato, is an immortal soul with three parts: rational, spirited, and appetitive.
  • True understanding of the self is achieved through knowledge of the Forms, which transcend physical reality.
  • Justice in the individual reflects the health of the state, where one's actions are aligned with the Good and Truth.

Plato mentions the self in the following books:

  • "The Republic" (circa 380 BCE): Plato discusses the self in relation to the soul's immortal nature and its role in understanding reality, emphasizing self-awareness and virtue.

  • "Phaedrus" (circa 370 BCE): In this dialogue, Plato explores the concept of the self through the lens of love and rhetoric, highlighting the interconnectedness of the soul and the pursuit of wisdom.

  • "Phaedo" (circa 360 BCE): Plato discusses the self in the context of the soul's immortality and its journey towards enlightenment, emphasizing the importance of philosophical inquiry for self-realization.

  • "Symposium" (circa 385-370 BCE): Plato's dialogue examines the nature of love and beauty, offering insights into the self as it relates to desire and transcendence.

Plato’s Concept of the Self

Plato, the ancient Greek philosopher, had profound ideas about the self, seeing it as a complex entity governed by different parts. Your understanding of ‘the self,’ according to Plato, hinges on the condition of your soul and the pursuit of wisdom.

The Tripartite Soul

According to Plato’s theory, your soul consists of three parts: the logical, the spirited, and the appetitive. The logical part, which includes reason, should ideally govern the soul with wisdom, striving for truth and the good in life. The spirited part involves your emotions and desires, which must align with reason to ensure a virtuous character. Lastly, the appetitive aspect drives the basic needs and desires, and it needs to be regulated by reason to support a balanced life.

Self-Knowledge and Virtue

For Plato, self-knowledge is a crucial virtue. It's about knowing your true self, including your strengths, weaknesses, and the nature of your desires. It is believed that this insight into your inner workings fosters virtue—a quality that goes hand in hand with wisdom. By understanding yourself, you're more equipped to act justly and cultivate a harmonious soul, where each part fulfills its rightful role, guided by knowledge. Discovering and nurturing these elements lead you to the highest form of self-awareness and a just life.

Individual and State Relation

In Plato's philosophy, you'll find that the relationship between individual virtues and the state’s structure is crucial. This connection is thoughtfully explored through the lens of justice in both the individual soul and the political makings of a state.

Justice and Individual Virtue

For you to understand Plato's conception of justice, it's essential to recognize that he aligns the health of a state with the virtues found within its citizens. Plato argues that a just state mirrors a just individual, suggesting that the same virtues that create harmony in your soul are what lead to a harmonious society.

Justice, to Plato, is not merely a political construct but a personal one as well; it's realized when all the parts of your soul are in balance—the rational, spirited, and appetitive. Accordingly, the state reflects this justice when each class within it performs its designated function well.

Philosopher-King and the Ideal State

In an ideal state, Plato elevates the role of the philosopher-king as the epitome of governance. You would see the philosopher-king as a ruler who embodies wisdom, indicating that only those who genuinely understand what is good for the state deserve to lead.

The philosopher-king is not just a political ruler but also the personification of the virtues that Plato deems essential: wisdom, courage, moderation, and justice. Such a leader ensures that the state functions smoothly, similar to how sound reasoning directs your personal actions toward a balanced life.

Theory of Forms and Knowledge

In exploring Plato's philosophy, you'll find that the Theory of Forms is pivotal for understanding what true knowledge is. Here's how it helps dissect the intricate relationship between metaphysical entities and epistemological concepts.

Forms as Abstract Entities

Plato conceptualized Forms as the perfect, immutable archetypes of the various properties and objects we experience in the physical world. For instance, when you appreciate a beautiful painting or a stunning sunset, Plato would argue that you're perceiving the Form of Beauty. This Form is an abstract entity, existing independently of the beautiful things you see, and is the epitome of truth and perfection.

Epistemology of the Forms

Now, concerning knowledge, Plato believed that real understanding comes from grasping these Forms through reason. Since Forms are eternal and unchanging, true knowledge—according to Plato's epistemology—involves recognizing the Forms beyond sensory experience. So, when you come to 'know' something, it's about recalling the Forms' truth rather than simply experiencing the physical manifestations.

Psycho-Philosophical Dynamics

In understanding Plato's view of the self, you'll find that the dynamics between desire and reason within the soul are central. Plato's work goes deep into how these elements interact to shape character and virtue.

Desire and Reason

Your desires represent the appetite part of your soul, constantly seeking satisfaction through things like food, drink, and other pleasures. Plato sees it as a fundamental part of your existence. But it's your reason, the rational part of the soul, which seeks truth and wisdom that must govern these desires. He argues that when reason rules over desire, it leads to a well-ordered soul, which is essential for achieving virtue and, consequently, true happiness.

Moral Psychology

Moral psychology is where emotions intertwine with reason in your quest for a virtuous life. Plato's psycho-philosophical view suggests that emotions are not just irrational bursts of feeling, but rather, they can be informed by reason and thus contribute to the moral quality of your actions. For instance, an emotion like anger can be appropriate if directed by reason towards injustice. He advocates for a balanced soul, where rationality guides your emotional responses, fostering inner harmony and allowing you to develop a character rooted in wisdom and virtue.

Dialogue and Dialectic Method

In Plato's works, the dialectical method embodies the core of philosophical inquiry, and dialogue is the vessel through which you explore the self and the world. Let’s dive deeper into these concepts and how they interact.

Dialectic as Philosophical Tool

Dialectic is the art of reasoning and logical argumentation that Socrates employs to uncover the truth. Plato sees dialectic as the highest form of philosophy, a way to ascend from the shadows of the material world to the clarity of metaphysical understanding. As a philosophical tool, dialectic involves a rigorous logic that dissects and examines ideas to affirm their validity. It's about questioning assumptions and challenging beliefs to move closer to the truth. It's a method where no sophist trickery finds a home - just the honest and often challenging pursuit of knowledge.

Role of Dialogue in Self-Discovery

The heart of Platonic philosophy pumps through the veins of dialogue. You'll find in Plato’s writings, characters like Socrates engage in conversations that are masterclasses in self-discovery. Through dialogue, you’re invited to participate in philosophical exercises indirectly, experiencing the pursuit of truth as a collective rather than a solitary venture. As participants in the dialogue method, you share in the dismantling of preconceived notions and rebuild your understanding from a more informed perspective. This method is not just about interpreting static text; it's an active engagement with philosophical ideas that encourages you to question and refine your understanding of the self in relation to the greater metaphysical reality.

Plato’s Key Dialogues on Self

Plato's profound exploration of the self is primarily showcased through his dialogues, which contain elemental discussions about the soul, justice, and love. These key themes in understanding the self are artfully unfolded in "The Phaedo," "The Republic," and dialogues on love like "Symposium" and "Phaedrus."

The Phaedo: Mortality and the Soul

In "The Phaedo," you encounter the concept of the immortal soul, which Plato suggests transcends the physical world after death. The dialogue explores the separation of the soul from the body, emphasizing that your true essence is not tied to your mortal shell. Plato presents the idea that knowledge is a form of recollection, and your immortal soul holds wisdom from past lives.

The Republic: Justice and Individual

Moving to "The Republic," Plato draws an analogy between the just society and the just individual. You'll learn how Plato imagines a well-ordered soul mirroring a well-ordered city, with each part performing its proper function. The dialogue suggests that justice is intrinsic to your well-being and is realized when every aspect of the self is in harmony.

Symposium and Phaedrus on Love and Self

In the dialogues on love, particularly the "Symposium" and "Phaedrus," Plato reflects on the role of love in understanding yourself. In these texts, your personal growth and search for truth are intertwined with the concept of love or Eros. The love discussed here prompts you to recollect and reconnect with the eternal Forms, which enlightens your understanding of the self.

Through these dialogues, Plato provides you with his philosophical blueprint of the self which encompasses aspects of morality, knowledge, societal roles, and profound love, all orchestrating to define who you are.

Influence and Criticism

Plato's thoughts about the self have left an indelible mark on philosophy, igniting discussions that continue to this day. You'll see how his ideas influenced the broader landscape of Western thought and how his most famous student, Aristotle, offered a contrasting viewpoint.

Impact on Western Philosophy

Plato’s exploration of the self through the lens of the soul has profoundly shaped Western ethics and moral philosophy. Many philosophers have been influenced by his ideas about the self's pursuit of knowledge and the notion of a life worth living. His work established a foundation that others built upon, exploring the tension between individual desires and the common good.

Aristotle and Plato’s Differences

Although a student of Plato, Aristotle diverged significantly in his beliefs about the self. He emphasized empirical observation and the importance of the physical world, contrasting with Plato's more abstract and idealistic perspective. You can think of Aristotle as grounding the concept of self in the here-and-now rather than in the realm of ideals.

End of content

No more pages to load